I know it sounds a little crazy, but after the arduous task of stripping five different wallpapers from this house, we’re actually considering putting some up again. I may have even hinted at the idea in an earlier post about the nursery mobile.

When we first designed the built-ins, we pictured adding an accent treatment between them—perhaps a painted color, a patterned wall, or a planked surface. Those ideas faded a bit once the built-ins were finished and filled with things; we didn’t want to overwhelm the space above the crib. Still, the idea of creating a focal point somewhere in the room wouldn’t leave us. One evening, while browsing wallpaper options, a particular pattern caught John’s eye.

He ordered samples without checking with me first—$5 each for the light and dark versions, and about $13 total with tax and shipping. It was the kind of impulse buy that could either earn him a disgruntled glance or make him a decorating hero.

My initial reaction was a sour look—not because of the cost, but because I remembered how miserable wallpaper removal had been in the past. When John pointed out that the sample wallpaper he chose was removable, my temper cooled. The pattern itself felt age-neutral, something that could grow with our child instead of feeling too juvenile for long-term use.

The samples arrived a couple of weeks later and were nice and large. Up close, they revealed a subtle linen-like texture in the gray tones, which we both liked. We taped them up in the room to see how they would look in context. John, getting braver by the day, taped one on the wall that already displayed the bike prints. Since neither of us wanted to change the built-in wall, he thought the bike wall might be the better spot for an accent.

To visualize the wallpaper on a full wall, I took a quick phone photo and used Photoshop to mock up a full-wall version. The process was simple: overlay the wallpaper sample photo on a wider shot of the wall, scale the pattern until it matched, then tile the sample to fill the space. I erased the portions of the overlay that covered fixed items such as frames, doors, and the changing table so the wallpaper appeared to sit behind them.

We also tested the darker sample in Photoshop, but both of us preferred the lighter version. To be thorough, I placed the wallpaper mock-up on several photos of the room to see how it interacted with the existing wall color and furnishings. The colors in the mock-ups aren’t perfectly accurate—curtains and some tones can look off in photos—but the exercise helped us confirm that the lighter pattern wouldn’t clash with the room’s palette.

I still worried the bike wall might look too busy in real life with the art, the built-ins, the mobile, and the patterned crib skirt all competing for attention. So we tested alternatives. One mock-up placed the wallpaper on the crib wall to revisit our original idea, but it felt overwhelming above the crib when combined with the many elements already present on that wall.

We also tried a bold green block above the crib to see whether a painted accent might work; it looked flat and didn’t win us over. A charcoal option that balanced the chair and crib was more promising—its darker tone felt cozy and paired nicely with the white crib and the mobile. A reader named Annie even sent a mock-up showing chunky painted stripes behind the crib, and that idea gave us pause as well. We’re fond of stripes, so that suggestion remains appealing.

For now we’re letting the ideas simmer. We’d love input: would you place removable wallpaper on the bike-art wall, choose a painted solid color like green or charcoal behind the crib, try stripes, or leave the room as it is? The removable nature of the wallpaper makes it a low-commitment experiment, and adding one more layer of interest might be a fun new adventure—especially since we’ve never actually put up wallpaper ourselves. At the same time, we want the nursery to feel playful and cozy rather than chaotic.

VOTING ON THIS POLL HAS CLOSED